Former SNP MP Mhairi Black has critiqued the Scottish Government, claiming they have mishandled policies and suggesting that the Scottish Parliament lacks significant power to affect people’s lives. Black, who became the youngest MP since 1832 when she won the seat of Paisley in 2015 at age 20, stepped down at the last general election. In a candid podcast interview, she mentioned her belief that John Swinney leans economically right-wing and labelled late First Minister Alex Salmond as a “charlatan” for establishing the Alba party.
Speaking on the Leading podcast, Black expressed her views, stating, “I think there are examples of where the Scottish Government have, over the last 17-odd years, for want of a better word made an arse of it. There’s no getting away from that.” She highlighted issues not with policy itself, but with the execution of policies. When asked if she would consider being an MSP, Black indicated that she would likely face disagreements that would lead to her expulsion from the SNP, given her potential diverging views.
Black also commented on current political figures within the SNP. She described Nicola Sturgeon and Humza Yousaf as left-of-centre leaders, while portraying John Swinney as economically right-wing. She shared her perception of Alex Salmond’s political stance, noting his shift over time. Black described Salmond as a charismatic figure with a significant ego, leading to challenges within the party.
Regarding the Salmond sexual harassment scandal, Black expressed her shock at the number of individuals who shared negative experiences with Salmond, particularly his alleged bullying behavior. She also criticised Salmond’s decision to appoint Peter Murrell, Nicola Sturgeon’s then-husband, as the SNP’s chief executive.
Reflecting on the SNP’s internal dynamics, Black highlighted divisions within the party, particularly on social and economic issues. She suggested that without the unifying goal of independence, the party could face internal fractures. Following a challenging election result, Black implied that these underlying divisions had become more visible to the public.
In conclusion, Mhairi Black’s recent statements shed light on internal criticisms within the SNP and reflect broader challenges within Scottish politics. Her candid insights provide a unique perspective on the complexities of policymaking and party dynamics within the Scottish political landscape.