Ex-NYPD Commissioner Declines Action Against Officers Involved in Brooklyn Bar Raid Now Under Federal Investigation
In recent developments, it has been revealed that former New York Police Department Commissioner, Edward Caban, declined to take disciplinary action against three officers following a raid on a Brooklyn bar. This incident is now part of a federal probe that is casting a shadow over the city’s law enforcement.
The decision not to discipline the officers came just days before Commissioner Caban resigned amidst a cloud of suspicion. Federal prosecutors are currently investigating allegations of corruption within both the police department and City Hall. This move by Caban is noteworthy, especially considering his propensity to ignore recommendations for disciplinary action against officers.
The situation is further complicated by accusations made by the owner of the Brooklyn bar involved in the raid, Shamel Kelly. Kelly claims that Commissioner Caban’s twin brother, James Caban, attempted to extort him in exchange for assistance in resolving issues with the local police. These allegations have prompted Kelly to cooperate with federal authorities as a potential witness.
This incident is just one of several investigations linked to Mayor Eric Adams’ administration, who himself is facing charges of bribery and illegal campaign contributions. While both Edward and James Caban deny any wrongdoing and have not been charged with crimes, the situation continues to unfold.
Kelly’s troubles with the police began after his bar secured a temporary liquor license in 2023. Allegations of harassment, fines, and unwarranted searches by officers culminated in a tumultuous encounter in April of that year. Despite filing complaints, Kelly found little reprieve and sought assistance through channels connected to City Hall, ultimately leading him to James Caban.
James Caban, who runs a consulting firm, offered to intervene with the local precinct for a fee, a proposition Kelly likened to a shakedown. Despite declining the offer, Kelly continued to face increased scrutiny from the police, eventually forcing him to close his business.
The Civilian Complaint Review Board substantiated misconduct claims against the officers involved in the bar raid, recommending disciplinary action. However, Commissioner Caban overrode these recommendations, sparing the officers from consequences. This decision has been met with criticism from Kelly, who deems it unjust.
As the federal investigation unfolds, questions continue to arise regarding the relationship between law enforcement, city officials, and private citizens. The outcome of these probes remains to be seen, as New York City grapples with the implications of alleged corruption within its ranks.